Feature

Tipner West

Portsmouth Harbour’s internationally important wildlife is at threat from Portsmouth City Council’s proposals to build a marine hub and housing at Tipner West, an area of land surrounded by wildlife-rich mudflats and coastal grassland on the north-eastern coast of Portsea Island.

Black-tailed Godwit, adult male in breeding plumage feeding in lagoon
On this page

The Council dropped their disastrous original plans for the Tipner West ‘super peninsula’ (AKA Lennox Point) which would have seen around 30ha of Portsmouth Harbour’s mudflats and coastal grassland concreted over. We’ve come a long way, but the current proposals set out in the final draft Local Plan would still destroy up to 2.9ha of Portsmouth Harbour's protected marine habitats, as well as another potential 3.6ha of protected coastal grassland which is important for roosting birds.

The RSPB is once again joining forces with the Hampshire & Isle of Wight Wildlife Trust to send a clear message to the Portsmouth City Council and the Government not to set a dangerous precedent by allowing the proposed development to destroy areas of the legally protected sites, but instead deliver a sustainable regeneration scheme that Portsmouth can be proud of. That means keeping the development within the ecological limits of the site and not building on vital habitats that are relied on by special wildlife.

You can join with us in demanding the Council and Government meet goals for housing and employment without building on protected sites: an immovable red line for nature.

Why is it worth fighting for?

Portsmouth Harbour is recognised internationally for its saltmarsh and vast expanses of mudflats and tidal creeks that provide shelter and a rich source of food for thousands of Dark-bellied Brent Geese and other waterbirds that visit here in search of warmer winter climes from their breeding grounds as far afield as Siberia and Greenland.

Whilst the need for employment and housing development is acknowledged, it is essential that nature does not pay the price. With the threats of climate change and global biodiversity collapse it is more important than ever that all new development is sustainable and that means building in harmony with nature.

If the proposals for Tipner West are allowed to go ahead it would also set a very damaging precedent threating the protection of all of our most important natural sites across the country.

We cannot keep trying to squeeze nature into smaller and smaller spaces. Once these sites are lost, they are gone forever.

How you can help

We have a short window of opportunity for Portsmouth residents and the wider public to respond strongly to the final draft Portsmouth Local Plan (the ‘Regulation 19 Pre-Submission’ consultation) and convince the Council and the new Government not to set the harmful ‘Portsmouth precedent’ and instead to support a wilder future for Tipner West that ensures the future of these protected nature sites. The consultation closes on 3rd September 2024.

All the details for how to send your message to Portsmouth City Council – and other ways to share the call for help – are on the Hampshire and Isle of Wildlife Trust’s e-action page here.

Our position

The RSPB recognises that Portsmouth needs sustainable employment development and new homes, just as nature needs homes, but the current proposals for Tipner West in the draft Portsmouth Local Plan still risk crossing key red lines for nature protection. 

We have worked together with the Hampshire and Isle of Wight Wildlife Trust to try to show the Council that there is a potential solution for Tipner West that meets the Council’s goals for housing and development while safeguarding the sites protected for nature. We have tried to show the Council that it doesn’t need to settle on an option that bulldozes over parts of the protected area for nature, as this would set a dangerous national precedent and wreak havoc for our local wildlife.  

We do not agree with the Council’s view that there are no other less damaging alternatives to the proposals set out for Tipner West in their draft local plan, nor that the need for this development is imperative for reasons of overriding public interest. Therefore the RSPB, along with the Wildlife Trust will be submitting an objection to the pre-publication draft Portsmouth Local Plan.

Timeline

  • July -September 2024

The final public consultation takes place on Portsmouth City Council’s draft Local Plan (prior to submission to the Government for examination) which includes a policy for Tipner West that would still cause direct damage to the internationally important wildlife sites.

The RSPB and Wildlife Trust launch another campaign to send a message to the Council and Government of support for a wilder future for Tipner West that ensures the future of the protected nature sites and does not set a dangerous precedent that allows nature protections to be overridden.

 

  • 2022-present

Portsmouth City Council consider options to deliver the marine hub and housing at Tipner West while taking advice from the statutory agencies, plus the RSPB and Wildlife Trust. Despite our strong advice, many of the options still include building over parts of the protected sites.

 

  • October 2022

Portsmouth City Council officially rule out the Tipner West super-peninsula option, but also rule out the ‘do nothing’ option for the site, setting new parameters for delivering the marine hub and new housing at Tipner West.

 

  • April 2022

The RSPB and Hampshire & Isle of Wight Wildlife Trust launch a challenge to Portsmouth City Council to consider an alternative option for Tipner West, an alternative that safeguards the protected sites whilst meeting the Council’s goals for housing and development. We also set out our key asks for any future development at Tipner West, and asked the public to join with us by contacting Portsmouth’s councillors and demanding that they #Don’tCrossTheLine.

 

  • December 2021

Following the ‘pause and rethink’ motion, the Tipner super-peninsular team presented a report to the Council. This has resulted in a cross-party working group of councillors re-examining the options for Tipner West.

 

  • November 2021

In partnership with Hampshire and Isle of Wight Wildlife Trust, we write to Sectary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities expressing our concerns with Portsmouth City Council’s approach to setting a new housing target and the proposals at Tipner West.

 

  • October 2021

​​​​​​​Portsmouth City Council votes to ‘pause and rethink’ the Tipner super-peninsula development, citing concerns over the environmental damage and public money spent to date (£10.8 million). The Council’s Cabinet is instructed to prepare a report on the status of the project outlining total spend to date, viable alternative options for Tipner West and a timeline for further decisions to be made. This report will be discussed at the Full Council meeting in December.

More than 9,000 people comment on Portsmouth City Council’s draft Local Plan through the Hampshire & Isle of Wight Wildlife Trust and RSPB campaign, expressing the importance of Tipner for wildlife and the impact the site has on their personal health and wellbeing.

The RSPB and Hampshire & Isle of Wight Wildlife Trust submit a joint response to Portsmouth City Council’s draft Local Plan setting out our strong opposition to the super-peninsula and raising concerns that it could undermine the Council’s entire Local Plan if they press ahead with the scheme.

 

  • September-October 2021

​​​​​​​Portsmouth City Council consult the public on their ‘Regulation 18’ draft local plan, including an option for the super-peninsula at Tipner West.

The RSPB and the Hampshire & Isle of Wight Wildlife Trust launch a new campaign encouraging people to voice their concerns about the super-peninsula.

 

  • March 2018

​​​​​​​The RSPB responded to Portsmouth City Council’s Tipner Strategic Development Area Consultation expressing our strongest objection to the reclamation of part of Portsmouth Harbour SPA and Ramsar site.  

Share this article